Case Question on Dabawala of Mumbai

In: Business and Management

Submitted By nimavatpankaj
Words 1881
Pages 8
Case Study on Dabbawallah of Mumbai

Submitted by : RIL -MDP
Taruna Upadhyaya
Pankaj Nimavat
Siddhartha Chaturvedi

Assignment Questions for the case:
1. What is the basis for the success of the Dabbawallahs of Mumbai? What factors need to be in place for a service like the Dabbawallahs to work effectively?
Basis for the success of the Dabbawallahs of Mumbai is that they were all working for a single purpose of delivering a dabba in time for the customer’s lunch. Several distinctive and supporting success factors include:
Dabbawallah Profile.
• All the dabbawallah were from the same geographical area and spoke the same language. This gave a kind of cultural profile to the Trust and high degree of cohesion amongst each other.
• High disciplined staff to ensure timely delivery. No strikes reported so far.
• Each dabbawallah considered themselves as entrepreneur and not employee which led to the high level of ownership and cohesive environment to work in.

Decentralization
• Each group was responsible for the smooth functioning of the day to day activities entirely independent of the trust.
• There were no centralized records of incomes and expenses for group clients, dabbawallah or Mukadams.
• Decentralization had been instrumental to building cohesion within each group, and operational autonomy helped to provide focus on delivery effectiveness and improvement.

Perceived Equality
• Each Dabbawallahs in the group earned equal remuneration; irrespective of the seniority and the amount of time and effort put.
• This system was leveler that helped forge equal relationships among the dabbawallah.
• The financial equality was leveled with the distribution of the work load with physical work being handled by younger generation over the older dabbawallah.

Delivery reliability
• There was no governing hierarchy that defined working relationships…...

Similar Documents

The Mumbai Job - a Strategy Negotiation & Conflict Management Case Study

...SNCM Case: The Mumbai Job It was a cloudy day in Bangalore when I got the email. The weather was cool and pleasant and I had just finished my lunch. The email changed the complacence and deep satisfaction in my mind. The mail was sent via the most popular online professional network which had become the most used website by headhunters and job hunters. September 2010 was not exactly the peak hiring season as the global economy was still showing no signs of recovery from the recession; and I was not actively looking for a job. So, I was pleasantly surprised to see an email from a big firm in India which sought to talk to me about an open position they had in Mumbai. Little did I know how much that one email would change the next few years of my life! I thought for a while about the invite and decided to “give it a try”. After all, I had nothing to lose if I didn’t make it through the first round of interviews. But secretly, I knew I would go all the way to the final round because I was an expert in a proprietary technology which was used in just 3 companies across India and I was the best trainer in that field. This was cemented by a line in the job description which required “training experience is a must”. So, at the back of the mind, I was just curious to know “what am I worth in the market today?” Thus, began my story which ended with the first salary negotiation of my life. About the Company L&T Infotech is a subsidiary of Larsen & Toubro (L&T), which is the largest...

Words: 3078 - Pages: 13

Case Questions

... CASE 01 - MYSTIC MONK COFFEE 1. Has Father Daniel Mary established a future direction for the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming? What is his vision for the monastery? What is his vision for Mystic Monk Coffee? What is the mission of the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming? 2. Does it appear that Father Daniel Mary has set definite objectives and performance targets for achieving his vision? 3. What is Father Prior’s strategy for achieving his vision? What competitive advantage might Mystic Monk Coffee’s strategy produce? 4. Is Mystic Monk Coffee’s strategy a money-maker? What is MMC’s business model? What is your assessment of Mystic Monk Coffee’s customer value proposition? its profit formula? its resources that enable it to create and deliver value to customers? 5. Does the strategy qualify as a winning strategy? Why or why not? 6. What recommendations would you make to Father Daniel Mary in terms of crafting and executing strategy for the monastery’s coffee operations? Are changed needed in its long-term direction? its objectives? its strategy? its approach to strategy execution? Explain. CASE 02 - COMPETITION AMONG THE NORTH AMERICAN WAREHOUSE CLUBS: COSTCO WHOLESALE VERSUS SAM’S CLUB VERSUS BJ’S WHOLESALE 1. What is competition like in the North American wholesale club industry? Which of the five competitive forces is strongest and why? Use the information in Figures 3.3, 3.4, 3.5, 3.6, and 3.7 (and the related chapter discussions on pp. 41-53) to do a complete five-forces......

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Case Question

...This is an outline of the three-step writing process to apply to cases. Answer all questions directly on this form. Then add a page break, and write your message in response to the case on the following page. For the three-step process questions, you may use short phrases and sentences for your answers. Student name? Javier Pita Case number and short name for case? Case number 12. Short name: Email privacy policy. I. Plan A. Analyze the Situation 1. What is your general purpose? The general purpose is to communicate the new email privacy policy of the Los Angeles Times. 2. What is your specific purpose? The specific purpose is to inform the bureau managers about the new email privacy policy and the penalties for the offenses. 3. Exactly what do you want your audience to think, feel or believe after receiving your message? I want my audience to feel and believe the importance of applying the new privacy policy about emails and to make sure that the penalties are implemented. 4. Who is your primary audience? My primary audience is the bureau managers. I need to inform them about the new policies and to let them know that there will be a more detailed memo in the future that will explain with more details the new policies. 5. What is their background? The primary audience has a very good background in the subject. They......

Words: 1215 - Pages: 5

Costco Case Questions

...Costco Case Questions 09/26/2013 Question 1: Competition in the North American wholesale club industry is high, with Costco being its leader at 56% of the market share. Main ways to compete are lower prices, more efficient operations, and reduced labor and overhead costs as well. Some of the clubs do the bare minimum in advertising while others, like BJ’s, spend more money on it (special Christmas radio advertisement and such). Out of the five competitive forces, the strongest is the rivalry between the competitors, because all of the players in this market attempt to offer high-quality products at lower prices. According to Figure 3.3, one of the reasons for rivalry amongst competitors to be strong is a relatively low cost to buyers to switch brands, and also if buyer demand is growing slowly, both of which are true in this case. All competitors in this industry are focusing on low margins on the products and high volumes of sales. Suppliers do have some power and influence on the wholesale club members, especially in the case with Costco, which buys some of its goods on the gray market and is known to sell some big-ticket items, but with globalization happening and more and more of suppliers being available around the world, they do not present a reason for concern as high as the rivalry between market players. Customers are always looking for lower prices and higher quality of merchandise, which Costco has been excellent at providing. BJ’s strategy is to give a better...

Words: 1292 - Pages: 6

Mumbai Dabbawallah

...livings, organization and culture of the six sigma winners “Mumbai Dabbawallas” Global Cuisine Reasearch Assignment Arjun Singh Arora Research Proposal Research Question An Investigation Study of the Life and Livings, Organisations and Culture of the Six Sigma Winners ‘ Mumbai Dabawalas’ Rationale The reason why I selected this topic is because I’m very fascinated towards the supply chain management line. I find this research interesting because the “Mumbai Dabawalas” are doing 4,00,000 transactions everyday without the help of any technology or educated manpower and are still able to deliver the tiffins on time and without any errors. Methodology To conduct the investigation study I mainly concentrated on secondary research by reading the various studies that have already been conducted by students from other management institudes. To gain more information I also watched a few lectures by Professor Pramod Agarwal (PHD on Supply chain management) and other documentaries such as “….” By BBC. Declaration I declare that this report is the result of my own individual efforts and that it conforms to university, departmental and course regulations regarding cheating and plagiarism. No material contained within report has been used in any other submission, by the author, for an academic award. Acknowledgement I would like to thank Chef Shankar Jha for helping me frame the research question for my report and would also like to thank him for his......

Words: 4155 - Pages: 17

Questions for Case

...Case: Dell Inc. in 2008 Questions for the Presenting Group 1. What is your evaluation of Michael Dell’s performance in his roles as Dell’s CEO and Chairman? How well has he performed the five tasks of crafting and executing strategy that were discussed in Chapter 2? 2. What are the elements of Dell’s strategy? Which one of the five generic competitive strategies is Dell employing? How well do the different pieces of Dell’s strategy fit together? In what ways is Dell’s strategy evolving? 3. Does Dell’s expansion into other IT products and services make good strategic sense? Why or why not? 4. Is Dell’s strategy working? What is your assessment of the financial performance that Dell’s strategy has delivered during fiscal years 2000-2008? Use the financial ratios presented in the Appendix of the text (pages 240-241) as a basis for doing your calculations and drawing conclusions about Dell’s performance. 5. What does a SWOT analysis reveal about the attractiveness of Dell’s situation in 2008? 6. Which company is competitively stronger—Dell or Hewlett-Packard? Use the weighted competitive strength assessment methodology shown in Table 4.2 of Chapter 4 to support your answer. 7. In what respects, if any, is Hewlett-Packard’s strategy in PCs more appealing or better than Dell’s strategy? 8. What issues and problems does Michael Dell need to address? 9. What actions and strategy changes would you recommend to Michael Dell to boost the company’s performance and its prospects...

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Case Questions

...Case Questions. A. Williams, 2002. 1. Evaluate the terms of the proposed $900 million financing from the perspective of both parties. How would you calculate the return to investors in this transaction? If you need more information, what information do you need? 2. What is the purpose of each of the terms of the proposed financing? 3. Conduct an analysis of Williams’ sources and uses of funds during the first half of 2002. How do you expect these numbers to evolve over the second half of 2002? What is the problem facing Williams? How did it get into this situation? How has it tried to address the problem it is facing? 4. Some might describe Williams as “financially distressed”. What evidence is there that Williams’ business may be compromised as a result of its previous financial decisions? 5. As the CEO of Williams, would you recommend accepting the proposed $900 million financing offer? If not, what alternatives would you pursue? B. Dividend Policy at Linear Technology. 1. Describe Linear Technology payout policy. 2. What are Linear’s financing needs? Should Linear return cash to its shareholders? What are the tax consequences of keeping cash inside the firm? 3. If Linear were to pay out its entire cash balance as a special dividend, what would be the effect on value? On the share price? On earnings? On earnings per share? What if Linear repurchased shares instead? Assume a 3% rate of interest. 4. What......

Words: 1021 - Pages: 5

Mumbai Dabbawala

...SUMMER INTERSHIP PROJECT REPORT ON “Dabbawala Employee Satisfaction Survey” At Mumbai Dabbawala SUBMITTED IN THE PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIRMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION BY SHRISH PRATAP SINGH Roll no – (0844370026) (2008-2010) EXCEL SCHOOL OF BUSINESS MATHURA (U.P) (Affiliated to U.P.Technical University,Lucknow) ACKNOWLEDEMENT A task undertaken without offering prayers to almighty and taking blessings from the elders is not a good beginning. Likewise the work completed without acknowledging the assistance to those who were always by my sides to make my efforts fruitful in the task left incomplete. In the beginning, I would like to express my sincere thanks to my Institute teachers for giving me an opportunity to take the practical experience of working life. I convey my sincere thanks to Mr Raghunath Medge or providing me the proper guidance and Mrs. Priyankya Gautam for providing me the opportunity to carry out research effectively and efficiently. I would also like to pay thanks to all my classmates and friends and my family members for co-operating with me and helping me to complete the project. (SHRISH PRATAP SINGH) PREFACE Quality without creativity is meaningless. As changes grow ever more unpredictable creativity is rapidly becoming recognized a core management skill. Today’s business environment demands that managers posses a wide range of knowledge skills and competencies, as well as sound understanding of......

Words: 14614 - Pages: 59

Case Questions

...Spring 2003 Professor Kose John The Super Project Case – Questions and Hints I have digested the data in Exhibit 6 to produce Modified-Exhibit#6, in the Excel Spreadsheet on my website.The management analysis in Exhibit 6 does not deduct depreciation from the project’s taxable income. I have done that in Modified-Exhibit#6. - In Exhibit 6, the first change in Net Working Capital occurs in period 1. I have kept that assumption in Modified-Exhibit#6. It is ok to move all changes in NWC back one period, if you prefer to do so. - The depreciation calculation uses an old formula that is no longer used in practice. I have explained the formula and derived depreciation and book values in Modified-Exhibit#6. Suppose you are responsible for making the final decision about the Super Project, on March 1967, and you have read all the data and the analysis in “The Super Project”. Should you go ahead with the project or not? I will help you out by asking a few specific questions, the type of questions you would have to ask yourself in a real world situations. Specific questions 1) Are the cash flows in Exhibit 6 or Modified-Exhibit#6 correct? Notice that the reason for including the cash flows in Exhibit 6 is explained in detail in the “The Super Project”. In particular, should General Foods include the following or not? Discuss briefly. a) Test market expenses; b) Charges for the use of Jell-O agglomerator capacity; c) Charges for erosion of Jell-O......

Words: 614 - Pages: 3

Case Questions

...Case #1: Butler Lumber Company Questions 1. Why does Mr. Butler have to borrow so much money to support this profitable business? 2. Do you agree with his estimate of the company’s loan requirements? How much will he need to borrow to finance his expected expansion in sales (assume a 1991 sales volume of $3.6 million)? 3. As Mr. Butler’s financial advisor, would you urge him to go ahead with, or to reconsider, his anticipated expansion and his plans for additional debt financing? As the banker, would you approve Mr. Butler’s loan request, and, if so, what conditions would you put on the loan? 4. Has Butler Lumber Company created value for shareholders? Hint: It might help you to analyze the case if you conduct the following analyses: 1. 2. 3. 4. Construct a common-size (percentage) income statement. Construct a common-size (percentage) B/S Using information from 1&2 to find out the operating efficiency Assuming the same operating efficiency in 1990, forecast cash needs for the target growth Case #2: Ocean Carriers Questions Ocean Carriers uses a 9% discount rate. 1. Do you expect daily spot hire rates to increase or decrease next year? 2. What factors drive daily hire rates? 3. How would you characterize the long-term prospects of the capesize dry bulk industry? 4. Should Ms Linn purchase the $39M capesize? Make 2 different assumptions. First, assume that Ocean Carriers in a U.S. firm subject to 35% taxation. Second, assume that Ocean Carriers is located in Hong Kong,......

Words: 947 - Pages: 4

Case Questions

...Questions to be discussed in class Case 18: Worldwide Paper Company 1. What are the yearly cash flows that are relevant for this investment decision? Do not forget the effect of taxes and the initial investment amount. 2. What discount rate should Worldwide Paper Company (WPC) use to analyze those cash flows? Be prepared to justify your recommended rate and the assumptions that you used to estimate it. 3. What is the net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR) for the investment? Case 24: Euroland Foods S.A. 1. Why does the company face the capital rationing? 2. Why do different types of projects have different hurdle rate (required rate of return) and maximum acceptable payback years? 3. Prepare to discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the various measures of investment attractiveness as used by Euroland Foods. Will all of the measures rank the projects identically? Why or why not? 4. Please rank the 11 proposals on the basis of purely economic considerations. Then rank them a second time based on any other considerations that you believe are important. Are the rankings identical? Why or why not? 5. Which set of projects should Wilhelmina Verdin recommend to the board of Euroland Foods for the capital budget for 2001? Role play Accompanying this assignment are the case and supplemental information on a role that you will be asked to represent. Please study the case and the role carefully, and prepare a preliminary...

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Case Questions

...52:620:530 D6 (Summer 2015) Arun Kumaraswamy Case preparation questions KTM – Ready to race (for general discussion in class) 1. Size up KTM (its strategy, resources/capabilities, organization and management) and its environment. How is it performing? 2. What growth options does it have? How does each growth option fit with its environment, strategy/resources/capabilities? How well can KTM deliver on each of these options? 3. What growth options should KTM pursue? Should it pursue organic growth (i.e., through internal development), merge/acquire (if yes, who) or use alliances? Newell Co: Corporate strategy (for general discussion in class) 1. Is Newell’s corporate strategy successful? Does the company add value to the businesses within its portfolio? 2. What are Newell’s distinctive resources and competencies? 3. What challenges does Newell face in the late 1990s? 4. Given this context, does the Calphalon acquisition make sense? Rubbermaid acquisition? Why (or why not)? Antitrust regulation in a global setting: The EU investigation of GE/Honeywell merger (for general discussion in class) 1. What markets are affected by the proposed GE/Honeywell merger? Who are the main competitors in these markets and how are these markets related to each other? 2. What would the combined market share of GE and Honeywell be in each of the markets you identified in Q1? How would these estimates change depending on how broad or narrowly you define these markets? 3.......

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Question for Case Memo

...Strategic Management Case Analysis & Presentation Questions for the case memos: Case 1: The Chinese Fireworks Industry Discussion Questions: 1. If you were Jerry Yu, would you invest in a Liuyang fireworks factory? Why? 2. Is the fireworks industry a ‘sunset’ industry or an industry still worth being in for the long run? 3. If you were Jerry Yu, and you decided to make the investment, what would you do to win out in the competition? 4. If you were asked to provide advice to Liuyang Firecrackers and Fireworks Industry Department, as Jerry Yu, what would you say? Case 2: The Global Casino Industry Discussion Questions: 1. Examine the structure of the casino industry by using Porter’s five forces model. 2. What has been the effect of the changing industry structure on U.S. casinos? 3. What are the strategic groups in the casino industry? 4. Assuming your group as consultancy for the Macau government, provide some recommendations for the gaining industry in Macau. Case 3: McDonald’s Discussion Questions: 1. What situation did Easterbrook inherit when he became CEO? What are the current forces in the external environment that might affect the new CEO? 2. What source of competitive advantage does McDonald’s have, and is that position supported by its value chain and other internal resources? 3. What steps could Easterbrook take to fix the problems McDonald’s faced? 4. What other strategies did McDonald’s formulate to achieve a competitive advantage? Case 4: Apple......

Words: 379 - Pages: 2

Case Questions

...Case Questions for April 10, 2010 Discussion Questions for Birch Paper Company Answer each of the following questions independently. 1. Which bid should Norhern Division accept? 2. Should Thompson Division lower its price? If so, to what? 3. What should the Commercial V.P. do? Case 23-5, Berkshire Industries 1. Were Berkshire’s motivations for a new incentive system reasonable? If so, what were their main options for a new system? Was an economic profit-focused system a reasonable choice? 2. Use the data pertaining to the Snack Food Division, as shown in Exhibit TN- 1, to calculate: a. Economic profit for the division for 2000 and 2001. b. The economic profit target for the division for 2001. c. The division manager’s bonus payout (% of salary) for 2000 and 2001. (Assume that the slope of the payoff line for 2000 was arbitrarily set by Berskshire management to equal 1.0). 3. Assume the base salary of the manager of the Snack Foods Division was ₤120,000 in both 2000 and 2001. How much cash would the manager receive from his bonus payouts in 2000 and 2001? 4. Evaluate the Berkshire Industries’ new incentive plan. What changes would you recommend, if any? 5. Should Mr. Embleton make special adjustments of the economic profit figures or the bonus payouts for personnel in the Spirits Division in 2000 and 2001? Why or why not? Sub-Micron Devices (take-home graded case, not due on April 10) Anwer the questions provided in the case...

Words: 253 - Pages: 2

Cases Questions

...2006 CASE QUESTIONS DR. KISS Please allow these questions to serve as a guide when you prepare your case write-up in accordance with the syllabus or other instructions. Table of Contents Page Case: Name and Number, Bruner 5e Note Number I. C12- Best Practices—WACC No Questions II. C2- Bill Miller & Value Trust 2 III. C5- Financial Detective, 2005 Contained in Case IV. C7- Body Shop Intl* Contained in Case, but see page 3 V. C6- Krispy Kreme Doughnuts, Inc. 4 VI. C17- The Investment Detective* Contained in Case VII. C28- Intro. to Debt Policy & Value* No Questions, but review M & M Theory on debt and value of the firm. VIII. HBS Case- “Leveraged Betas and the Cost of Equity No Questions IX. C16- The Boeing 7E 7* 5 X. C26- Jet Blue Airways, IPO Valuation* 6 XI.a C35- Merton Electronics 7 XI.b C36- Carefour S. A.* 8 XI.c C44- Palamon Capital Partners* 9 XII. GM Dividend Policy Negotiation (Information to be provided by Dr. Kiss) * Note: Excel Spreadsheets containing some of the exhibits from the case are available for this case at www.mhhe.com/bruner5e FIN 620, CASE QUESTIONS DR. KISS Please allow these questions to serve as a guide when you prepare your case write-up in accordance with the syllabus or other instructions Case 2- Bill Miller & Value Trust Suggested Questions for Your Preparation of the Case. ...

Words: 1437 - Pages: 6